Cowboy boots and winter boots: how to shop second hand footwear for the cold months

Boots are having a long moment. Cowboy boots are everywhere from the street to the catwalk, and when the temperature drops, a sturdy pair of winter boots goes from nice-to-have to essential.

The good news is that boots are one of the best things to buy second hand. Quality leather boots are made to be resoled, polished, and worn for years, so a pair with a little patina is often better than a new one. Here's how to find the right pair, whether you're after western style or all-weather warmth.

1. Real cowboy boots, not costume ones

The best cowboy boots are made from real leather with a stacked heel, a sturdy sole, and a shaft that holds its shape. Vintage pairs have a character that new ones take years to build.

What to look for: Search for Ariat, Frye, Tony Lama, Sendra, Lucchese, and Justin. Pointed and snip toes feel the most western, while a rounded toe is easier to wear every day. Check the inside leather and the sole for cracks.

2. Getting the fit right

Cowboy boots are meant to fit snugly at the heel and ankle, with a little room in the toe. They'll loosen slightly as the leather softens, so a very tight pair is usually a mistake.

Our secret bargain tip: Check the insole length in the item description and compare it with your favourite boots at home. If the heel slips a little at first, a thicker sock or a cushioned insole usually fixes it.

3. Waterproof winter boots

For rain, slush, and snow, you want a boot that keeps your feet dry and the cold out. Leather boots with a waterproof lining or rubber outsole get you through a whole winter.

What to look for: Search for Timberland, Sorel, Blundstone, Dr. Martens, Kamik and Hunter. Check the sole for deep, even tread, and make sure the inside of the boot is clean and free from cracks.

4. Shearling-lined and snow boots

When it gets properly cold, a lined boot makes a huge difference. Shearling and wool linings keep warmth in and are naturally good at handling moisture.

What to look for: Look for UGG, Moon Boot, Bearpaw, Sorel, and Kamik. A slightly flattened lining is normal, but avoid any pair with a persistent smell or visible damage inside.

5. Keeping your boots in shape

A little care keeps a good pair going for years.

How to care for them: Wipe off dirt and salt as soon as you get home, stuff the boots with paper to dry, and never place them next to a heater. Condition leather every few weeks in winter, use a waterproofing spray on suede, and keep cowboy boots upright with boot shapers so the shaft doesn't fold.

Below we've linked a selection of our curated Sellpy Edits to help you find your perfect pair of cowboy boots or winter boots.